Enterprising African Entrepreneurs Continue To Be Targeted by Unverified Watchdogs
In July 2014, Mohammed Kozbar, chairman of Finsbury Park Mosque in north London, received a letter from the mosque’s bankers, HSBC, that left him astonished.
The
letter informed him that the mosque’s banking services would end because it
fell outside the bank’s “risk appetite”. There was no detailed explanation, and
the mosque’s trustees said they had not been contacted beforehand or given an
opportunity to address any concerns. Kozbar said there had been no previous
issues between the mosque and HSBC, and he could not understand what had
happened.
The
situation became more difficult when other banks also refused to accept the
mosque as a customer. Without a banking relationship, an organisation can
struggle to receive donations, pay bills and carry out its activities. Kozbar
was left trying to understand why the account had been closed and how the
mosque could continue its work without access to banking services.
Kozbar’s
experience is a reflection of a wider problem that organisations find
themselves in. Shut out of financial services without a clear explanation of
the concerns against them or a practical way to address them, many businesses
have been left to bear harsh consequences. According to the Fintech Rating Company, the total
number of high-risk business banking disruptions in
2025 alone is estimated at 7,000-9,000 incidents.
Information
Carries Consequences
But
the story got interesting in 2015 when the mosque learned that it had been
listed in World-Check, a risk intelligence database operated by Thomson Reuters and used by
banks and other institutions for screening. Its profile placed the mosque in
the “Terrorism” category, relying on press reports and allegations dating from
before the mosque’s reorganisation in 2005.
In
February 2017, the dispute reached open court. Thomson Reuters apologised and
agreed to pay damages and legal costs after admitting that its profile
contained a false allegation suggesting grounds to suspect the mosque had
continued connections to terrorism. The company withdrew the allegations and
expressed regret.
Finsbury
Park Mosque said in a statement:
“It
is unacceptable that any organisation is able to designate people as terrorists
on the basis of poor research and for those people to be labelled without any
recourse to truth or justice.”
This
case shows how information created for risk assessment can influence decisions
far beyond its original source. When that information is inaccurate or
outdated, the consequences can reach people who may not even know the profile
exists.
While
this is not an argument against financial screening – banks have legitimate
responsibilities to identify money laundering, terrorist financing and other
risks – the concern is what happens when information used to assess those risks
is unreliable, lacks context or is difficult for the people affected to
challenge. What happens when information presented as a warning is difficult to
verify or challenge?
Watchdogs
as part of the Problem
This
question matters when examining websites that publish allegations about people,
businesses and organisations while presenting themselves as watchdogs.
In
October 2026, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD) published an investigation into a network
of websites that included AMLNetwork, NGO Report and Brussels Watch. FDD
identified technical connections between the sites and argued that their output
advanced Qatari interests. These are findings and conclusions from FDD’s
investigation, not a judicial determination.
The
investigation also raises questions about transparency. When a website does not
identify its owners or editorial staff, readers have fewer ways to assess its
independence or hold those responsible accountable.
A
review of AMLNetwork’s African-focused pages raises further concerns. The pages
examined do not name individual authors, some refer to companies using letters
rather than their actual names, and the articles follow noticeably similar
structures.
One
case analysis concerns Sindika Dokolo, who died in October 2020, before
AMLNetwork appeared in 2023. His inclusion raises questions about the
timeliness of the material and the care taken in presenting it.
These
observations do not establish that every claim published by AMLNetwork is
false. They do, however, make it reasonable to ask how the claims were
researched and whether readers can independently assess the evidence behind
them.
For
the people and businesses named in such publications, the consequences are not
merely reputational. Allegations can be encountered by banks, business
partners, regulators or prospective clients as warning signs. A claim that has
not been properly tested can influence decisions about accounts, contracts and
commercial relationships. Those affected may then have to explain themselves to
institutions without knowing exactly what information has shaped the decision.
Repetition
Can Look Like Confirmation
The
problem becomes more complicated when material from one source is repeated or
cited elsewhere.
FDD
reported that websites in the network had received citations from other
institutions. Its examples included British think tanks citing NGO Report and
an AI-generated response it examined citing AMLNetwork.
A
citation does not automatically mean that an institution endorses every claim
on a website. However, these examples illustrate how information can acquire an
appearance of credibility through repetition. A claim appearing in several
places may look independently verified, even when those sources rely on the
same underlying material.
For
people and businesses named in such reporting, that distinction matters.
Potential partners, customers, journalists and researchers may encounter an
allegation without having the time or resources to trace it to its original
source. Repetition can give a disputed claim a longer life and make it harder
to separate what has been established from what has merely been reported.
What
we should do
There
are existing ways to challenge inaccurate or unlawful information, including
legal action and screening providers’ correction procedures. But correcting a
database entry does not necessarily remove the original webpage, just as
correcting a webpage does not guarantee that every copy or record based on it
will be updated.
The
difficulty is that the process of correction often involves several separate
parties. Someone affected may have to approach the publisher, the database
provider and the institution relying on the information. Meanwhile, decisions
can be made before a challenge is resolved. Even when a correction is
eventually published, it may not reach everyone who encountered the original
allegation.
This
makes transparency and accessible dispute procedures important. Publishers need
to identify who is responsible for their work, substantiate serious allegations
and give those concerned a fair opportunity to respond. Screening providers
need to distinguish verified findings from uncorroborated claims and make it
possible for affected parties to challenge inaccurate profiles.
Institutions
using screening information also have a responsibility to examine its source,
context and reliability rather than treating every online mention as
conclusive. Where information has influenced an adverse decision, affected
customers should receive a meaningful explanation, subject to legitimate legal
and security restrictions.
These
measures do not prevent legitimate reporting or genuine risk warnings. They
help ensure that decisions with serious consequences are based on information
that can withstand scrutiny.
The
Finsbury Park Mosque case demonstrates what can happen when inaccurate
information enters systems that influence important decisions. Thomson Reuters
eventually acknowledged the false allegation and expressed regret, but the
dispute had already affected the mosque’s banking relationships.
Thus,
the responsibility for reliable information cannot rest only with the person or
organisation being scrutinised. Those who publish allegations must be able to
support them. Those who repeat them must consider their origins. And those who
act on them must examine whether the information is credible and relevant.
Until
those who publish, repeat and act on suspicion are held to the same standard of
proof they demand of everyone else, accountability in financial scrutiny will
remain incomplete.

Comments
Post a Comment